Hockey's Future Prospect of the Year, 2012
View Single Post
04-29-2012, 06:59 AM
Join Date: Apr 2009
Originally Posted by
Just because THN messed that one up doesn't mean he isn't a top 50 talent. Granted he isn't going to upset Tarasenko, but 60 goals in a year deserves some credit...
The fact that THN kept him out of the top 3 was proof that they put too much stock into the WJC.
1 company makes a mistake because they base 80% of the ranking on WJC, how does this justify repeating the mistake...
Its fine, nobody gives Ducks prospects respect until the leave the Ducks (Tangradi, Schultz, Gardiner). If Etem was a Canadian team's prospect he would be hyped to the point of a top 10 prospect.
Maybe you guys should ensure that you have at least
notion of what you're talking about before writing? Every year there are people not just dismissing the FW ranking, but also pretending to know just what huge shortcoming or bias is preventing THN from seeing the light and sharing their hard-on for some prospect or other. And then it turns out they are clueless about the basics of how that ranking is compiled and hence what it reflects: The THN ranking is based on
the rankings of ca. 20 NHL scouts
, not on some biased THN office poll. It is more than justified to assume the result of that exercise is a reasonable approximation of the general judgment of the NHL scouting community at the time, and hence meaningfully reflects the reputation of a prospect within that community. Probably counts for a little bit more than Pete in Cleveland who's sitting in front of his keyboard and have managed to convince himself that only rampant bias or idiotic over-reliance on the WJC could possibly explain why his favorite prospect isn't rated.
As for Etem, he wasn't ranked that high last year either. Presumably for the reasons observers have been pointing out for years and which nearly pushed him out of the first round, such as an underdeveloped all-round game and limited decision-making. 60 CHL goals or not, he has never been regarded as a top-flight prospect and he isn't regarded as one now.
The Ducks, by the way, have several other of their porspects highly commended in the same issue. In fact, four of them are ranked ahead of Etem.
Last edited by Qvist: 04-29-2012 at
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Qvist