: Value of:
Ryan McDonagh & Dan Girardi
View Single Post
05-31-2012, 03:47 PM
Join Date: Dec 2011
Originally Posted by
Again, he plays the 2nd most minutes on your team. It makes him your #2. He isn't behind Chara and Weber either. Both he and Girardi are excellent defenseman, but he isn't a #1. #1 defensemen play in all situations including PP. He was 3rd in PP time behind MDZ and Girardi. He's a #2 guy, time will tell if he develops into a #1. Some guys just don't improve at the rate you hope they will. See Phaneuf and Doughty as prime examples. Phaneuf had 20 goals and 49 points as a 19 year old defenseman his first year. He also played shutdown minutes. Players have different development curves. Maybe McDonagh becomes a true #1 like Weber or Lidstrom, but maybe he peaks now.
Of course if you mean #1 as in a top 30 guy in the league I agree with you that he is that. But that would make Jokinen a #1 center too.
Lmao McDonagh has been our best D, Girardi was extremely good too. But McDonagh has put up good numbres and he played +25 min in reg season and +27 mins in the playoff. McDonagh has been best overall. Girardi has been super good too. But McDonagh beat him by a small margin. Look at the plays he makes. 1 game for instance against the Devs he skates backs and stops Parise and then later Kovalchuck on a breakaway. Minutes aren't everything bro. When healthy and in form Crosby plays more than Malkin making Malking the #2. That doens't mean Malkin isn't a #1 star player...
Whatever, arguing with you is like trying to learn Scott Gomez how to score again. It can't be done. It just hurts too much.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by RyanCallahan24*