Official NYR "Untouchables" Poll / Discussion
View Single Post
05-31-2012, 06:21 PM
Join Date: Apr 2012
Reasoning: Richards and Kreider obviously the top of this list. Irreplaceable to a point. Stepan has a ton of potential still. He came in year 2 and performed beyond expectations. He's handicapped by his shot and skating, but he'll be affordable and hold a spot at second line center for years to come. JT Miller and JAM are untouchable for the time being as well.
Reasoning: MDZ is replaceable and at his highest value since rookie year-- probably peaked right now in terms of value. Erixon's replaceable. Girardi is a rare right-handed guy. No real defense prospects that are untouchable at all. I wouldn't entirelyyy put Staal off the market. His return's probably pretty great, the injury history is scary, and he's put to waste on the second pairing.
All guys can be moved for enough return tbh; however, of the ones I listed I can't see any return being enough for Kreider or McDonagh
lundqvist too of course but that goes without saying
View Public Profile
Kreider Typical's albums
Find More Posts by Kreider Typical