Ryan Smyth potential free agent signing
View Single Post
06-01-2012, 10:14 AM
Join Date: Jun 2004
Originally Posted by
These type of posts are hilarious. Guys come here and contribute to win a Cup 1st time in 50 effin' years, but we could have done it without this guy or that guy.
Campbell didn't play well enough to stay etc.
Well boys, Brouwer, Burish, Kopecky, Sopel, Madden, Campbell... are all gone. How easy has it been to replce them?
Any deep playoff runs lately? There were 2 deep runs with them, the 2nd got us a Cup.
But it's true. Replacing Nick Boynton isn't tough.
Campbell was great and there's a reason he was making seven million per. Key piece that I wish nothing but the best for in Florida.
Brouwer had a bad playoff, understandable considering his father's poor health at the time. Outside of a solid series against the Sharks however, he was more or less invisible.
Burish is a quality fourth line energy guy that was great in the lockerroom. Certainly valuable, but far from irreplaceable.
Everyone knows I'm all about #82. His role on that cup team was to play spot minutes on the fourth line. Didn't really get his chance to prove his worth til the following season.
Sopel sucked. Have been saying it for three years now. Good riddance. Aaron Johnson would have been a better #5 then Sopel. Total warrior that left it all out on the ice, but he just wasn't a NHL caliber defenseman. He'd block three shots in a row, and then when he had the chance to clear the puck he'd make a tape to tape pass right back to the point.
Madden was another elite fourth line guy. Great signing, great mentor, great leadership. Would have loved to have had him back at a greatly reduced cost, which wasn't going to happen with our cap troubles.
Some of those pieces are nice, but outside of Cambell, all can be replaced every summer through trades/UFA without much difficulty outside of MAYBE Brouwer, and I'm not gonna prod that hornet's nest again.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by DisgruntledHawkFan