Quote:
Originally Posted by NitHeel
I wouldn't give JvR and a top-10 pick for Ryan (and Schenn is worth much more then then just a pick in the back of the top-10 anyway.
I wouldn't give #20, #45, and next year's #20 for #6 unless gold fell to that spot. I looked through the last few drafts and didn't see anything like a move from 20 to 6 so there's really no precedent to look at.
I'm not claiming to have the only correct opinion, but yeah, it is at the very least debatable.
|
I probably wouldn't either, but that's fair worth for that pick. You can look at what it costs to move from the 20th to the mid teens, then from the mid teens to the low teens. And then extrapolate what it would take from 12 to 6.
Throwing players into the mix skews everything, I'm just going off what recent trades have said the picks are worth.
Just some food for thought on 1st round trades for picks (not players)
2011 - #22 for #30 + #39
2010 - #15 for #19 + #59
2010 - #22 + #113(4th) for #27 + #57
2010 - #30 for #35 + #58
2009 - #12 + #77(3rd) for #26 + #37 + #62(3rd) + #92(4th)
2009 - #12 for #16 + #77(3rd) + #182(7th)
2009 - #20 for #23 +#84(3rd)
2009 - #21 for #26 + #37
2009 - #29 for #32 + #75(3rd)
2008 - #5 for #7 + 2nd + 3rd
2008 - #7 for #9 + #40
2008 - #12 for #17 + #28
2008 - #12 for #13 + 3rd
2008 - #15 for #18 + 3rd
2008 - #21 for #24 + 3rd
Gave up on the rest of 2008, too many trades
2007 - #16 for #19 + 2nd
2007 - #18 for #24 +3rd
2007 - #21 for #30 + 2nd
2007 - #28 for 2 2nd's
It would be a minimum of 2-3 trades to get from 20 to 10-12, with increasingly higher 2nd's and 3rd's to do so each time, then at least another 2 high 2nd's to get from 10 to 6. I'm pretty sure Philly doesn't have 4-5 2nd's to trade, so it would take another mid-low 1st.
You may not like it, you may not trade it, but that's the worth of Philly's picks based on the recent market.