Thread: Proposal: Nyr-car
View Single Post
Old
06-30-2012, 12:44 PM
  #5
bernmeister
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 9,774
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by nyrangers808 View Post
Rangers:

Dubinsky
Staal
2nd (Or 1st)

Carolina:

McBain
Skinner

Carolina gets a top 2 Dman and third Staal, as well as defensive forward Dubinsky and a pick
Rangers get a replacement for Staal, who is another Wisco guy to convince Schultz to sign, as well as their young top six winger
Value seems in the general ballpark, but not the package Canes go for.

counter-proposal
MStaal
Stepan
Brian Boyle
D prospect Mikhail Pashnin (seems to have rep of being a sparkplug, but goes to Russia rather than sit in NHL)
Rangers 2nd 2013
Rangers 2nd 2014

Skinner
McBain
Carolina 1st 2013
Carolina 1st 2014 (can be pushed to '15 or '16 instead)
========

rationale:
Skinner is best player, but MStaal + Stepan is too much, so 'canes need add.

Skinner = idealized version of Stepan, who already is full equal of Skinner except as to scoring touch. This makes Carolina stronger at pivot, more shutdown at D.

Rangers upgrade at F, downgrade at D, but get upgrade on picks

bernmeister is offline   Reply With Quote