Luongo XIX - The Return Is Not Phaneuf
View Single Post
07-04-2012, 08:25 AM
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Motel 35
Originally Posted by
Every time I see a quantity for franchise player deal I get worried.
Luongo was traded for
Auld - promising goalie ---> career backup
Bertuzzi - 1st line powerforward --> severe regression to a 2/3rd liner
Allen - top 4 d-man with potential --> #4/5 on a contender
Phaneuf was traded for
Stajan - 55 point #2C --> overpaid #4C
Hagman - 2nd line W --> 4th liner
White - #3/4 d-man --> #4 d-man
Anytime a star player is traded for 2nd tier assets from a lesser hockey club the lesser assets usually regress.
I think it's because the lesser players (tweeners like Kulemin/MacArthur or "#1 goalies" like Auld) enjoy top 6 time and opportunities on a bad team. When they're relegated to a lesser role their production dips.
If I was Gillis I hold out til I can get 1 good player back.
as an Oiler fan, it pains me to see such an intelligent post from a Canuck fan.
View Public Profile
Mr Sakich's albums
Visit Mr Sakich's homepage!
Find More Posts by Mr Sakich