Thread: Value of: Ryan Whitney
View Single Post
07-17-2012, 12:51 AM
Hall for captain
nabob's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: HF boards
Country: Canada
Posts: 9,035
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Whydidijoin View Post
I have seen none of these top-5 draft and Doughty claims you are making. Links or it didn't happen.

Also, when people make draft claims like that, they are comparing a 22-year old to 17-18 year olds (most average prospects who haven't busted would have the same thing said about them), and when they make comparisons, it is in style, not potential. Big difference. Stralman was compared to Lidstrom by his old coach, and it was blown out of proportion in a similar way you are now.

The comparison of Schultz and Gardiner happened BEFORE Gardiner jumped ahead in development by leaps and bounds last year, a key point that people like you fail to mention.
Article from end of June where Wisconsin coach says he is ahead of Gardiner and compares him to Suter


Hes as good as Gardiner is right now, said Prendergast. Hes well ahead of the learning curve for his age. Hes not just a puck-mover. Hes good defensively, too. When I would see him at Wisconsin, hed stand out. For sure, hed stand-out. The kids a player.

...Some scouts think hes similar to Drew Doughty.

Read more:
"The team that signs him could reasonably expect him to step onto their second pairing and be good on the power play from the get-go, which would be a great asset, with the ability to be even greater down the line."

Bob McKenzie ‏@TSNBobMcKenzie
Never any guarantees with any player but you would be hard pressed to find an NHL scout who doesn't think Schultz has tremendous upside.

Im not going to waste any more time finding quotes and links for you as you obviously have decided that since he is now an Oiler that he wont play top 4 minutes in the NHL.

nabob is offline   Reply With Quote