Paper about Canadian identity and ice hockey
View Single Post
08-09-2012, 04:14 AM
Join Date: Sep 2011
Originally Posted by
On page 24, you contrast Don Cherry and others supporting a traditional Canadian hockey "dominant, war-like" spirit with a traditional stereotype of Canadians as modest, polite, and diplomatic. Yet these two things are not in conflict. The traditional view is that Canadians don't talk a big game or draw attention to ourselves. We just get it done on the ice. See Bobby Orr, Don Cherry's favourite hockey player. He was a very humble, unassuming man who just put his head down after he scored, but he was as tough as they come on the ice as well.
Your discussion about the conflicts between the business of modern NHL hockey and Canadian identity are spot on. NHL teams have, in the past few decades, tried to be public institutions where it benefitted them, and private organizations where it benefitted them. Always ready to appeal to civic pride for a government handout, and also ready to pull up and leave if they can make more money elsewhere. It's a disgrace and it isn't particularly Canadian either. The real Canadian hockey spirit is in the thousand of small rinks around the country, not in the ice palaces extorted from taxpayers by greedy billionaires and filled with corporate suits deducting their high ticket cost as a business expense.
Thank you for Jagomir and Silver for the grammar fixes.
And I have to admit, overpass, that you raise a valid point. This might be a thing I must rewrite. Since I think there's still a weird oxymoron with the way patriotism is present with the stereotype to an excess, but this might just the flabbergasted me, who was dumbstruck with the amount of military-related topics on HNIC once watching it became a routine in Canada. But maybe the Summit Series and its violence is something I might have to focus on with an additional chapter. I will get back to this. Thanks for the notice.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by turkulad