View Single Post
Old
08-13-2012, 02:02 PM
  #58
matt1396
Registered User
 
matt1396's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Toronto
Country: Canada
Posts: 3,779
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by leafinsider View Post
I will break down the trade myself to see how fair it is to outsider views.

Devon Setoguchi:
NHL12 Rating 84
19 goals, 36 points
Possible regression, expected 82-84 rating

Ryan Suter
NHL12 Rating 87
7 goals, 46 points
Rating has been shown to be 87 on screenshots for NHL 13

For:

Wayne Simmonds
NHL12 Rating 83
28 goals, 49 points
Expected rating increase 83-85

Nicklas Grossman
NHL12 Rating 82
11 assists
Expected to stay around the same at 82

Max Talbot
NHL12 Rating 80?
19 goals, 34 points
Expected rating increase so we will say 82 ish

2013 Philly 2nd Round Pick
-Think what a 2nd round pick can land you in the NHL, bottom pairing D, bottom 6 effective forward etc...

Thats about as fair as a deal gets in my opinion. I would like to hear your rebuttals.
The ratings are going down this year for guys like Talbot as they want to make the gap between star players like Crosby and fourth liners like Colton Orr far away. That trade just isn't fair. You should at least be giving up a top 6 forward in that trade and a better defenceman then Grossman.

matt1396 is offline   Reply With Quote