The MLD 2012 Assassination Thread
View Single Post
08-19-2012, 04:46 PM
10 Years of ATDing
Join Date: Sep 2004
Originally Posted by
Basically, we don't know enough about either guy to really make a legitimate claim about how good they were.
So,... you think we know a lot about a guy who did great in a third-tier level (Czech league 50s) and well in second tier play (international 1940s-1950s), but we don't know enough about a guy who did very well in the top tier level of his time, against the best of his era?
I don't get how one person could hold both judgements, about Zabrodsky and Paton, unless one appeals to the fact that
Zabrodsky is on your squad versus Paton being on a divisional rival's
Why the scepticism on the one hand and faith on the other? especially given the two radically different levels of competition?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by VanIslander