Thread: Proposal: Nj-tor
View Single Post
08-28-2012, 07:12 PM
Registered User
Zippy316's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 6,143
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Spitsfan67 View Post
OMG This has to be a Toronto fan once again WAY OVER VALUING there player Toronto has to add to get volchenkov alone...he has to be one of the most under rated guys in the league....I mean defensively he IS one of the best in the league He'll jump in front of every shot and is great with his stick and can hit hard.MAcarthur IS a good 2 way forward that will put up 45-55points a season IF He can stay healthy but Volchenkov definitely has the edge over MAC...

IMO this is fair:

3rd 2013

To Toronto:
Volchenkov is overrated, in fact, and this is coming from a Devils fan. He's become more of a defensive specialist in New Jersey. He's great at what he does, so the Devils don't expect more of him.

The problem is it's doubtful he waives his NMC, and I would love to see what more we could get for him rather than MacArthur.

MacArthur more or less upgrades are depth, but the Devils currently have a problem with top-end talent. To the above poster, MacArthur has had one breakout season of 60 points, when he was playing top-six minutes. Zubrus pretty much has the same splits as MacArthur, hovers around 40 points had a breakout season of 55+, but other than that, it's 20g 20a. I like Zubrus though because he brings a great possession game and he can play on any line in any role. Not too sure what type of a player MacArthur is, but in my opinion, Zubrus is better because of the versatility.

Zippy316 is offline   Reply With Quote