Thread: Speculation: Jamie Benn
View Single Post
09-04-2012, 02:14 PM
Karitimes's Avatar
Join Date: May 2010
Location: NS
Country: Canada
Posts: 2,128
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Spitsfan67 View Post
Ok man when Benn was drafted in 2007 with the 129th pick in the draft did you or anyone else think he would be a first line player and a "Allstar" I'd say no Kass and Gaunce were first players and your trying to say they can't be first line players ever well give your heads a shake...Benn was a big surprise and has growed past his potential and past what people thought a kid would be drafted 129 no one thought any thing of him when he was drafted that far down in proposals on this site he would have been a nobody 4 years ago...Kass and Gaunce were drafted 9th overall and 26th overall in the FIRST Round not in the fifth and for you guys to think there just going to be iffy 3rd liners is just stupid
I'll offer Nystrom (10th overall) 16 goals last year and 12 more than Kassian, Glennie (8th overall) - good year in the in minors is pretty well NHL ready so further along the development curve than Guance, and Fistric (28th overall) - solid, zero offense hard hitting Dman very comparable to Tanev



Same logic... 2 top 10 overall draft picks and a nothing defenseman should land you someone really good and proven. Our 2 top 10 picks can still be first liners, Fistric might get more than 2 assists next year and Kesler is only a second liner anyway, he's overachieved too, so we good?

It's silly.

Like you say, 4 years ago, no one knew about Benn. He's come from playing for Victoria in the BCJHL to being the centerpiece of the Stars franchise. You couldn't put value enough on that type of development, nor could you put together enough value in assets on what the next 5 years leading into to his prime might look like for Benn. You don't trade a special player... it would be stupid.

Karitimes is offline   Reply With Quote