Quote:
Originally Posted by tarheelhockey
Since this has become a sort of campaign slogan for my opponent...
Medicine Hat Tricks
| Player | 2010 Placement | 2011 Placement | | Brian Campbell | MLD #192 | MLD #31 | | Bill Brydge | AAA #156 | MLD #106 | | Percy Traub | AAA #118 | MLD #169 | | Ted Graham | undrafted | MLD #253 | | Bob Trapp | AAA #72 | MLD #54 | | Dale Tallon | MLD #348 | MLD #97 | | Risto Siltanen | MLD #242 | MLD #85 | | Coddy Winters | MLD #175 | MLD #293 | | Bryan Watson | AAA #190 | MLD #345 |
Winston-Salem Polar Twins
| Player | 2010 Placement | 2011 Placement | | Brad Maxwell | ATD #633 | ATD #686 | | Arnie Brown | MLD #290 | MLD #144 | | Albert Langlois | AAA #53 | ATD #882 | | Jocelyn Guevremont | MLD #287 | MLD #10 | | Dave Ellett | MLD #225 | ATD #776 | | Garth Butcher | MLD #381 | MLD #143 | | Udo Kiessling | MLD #165 | ATD #869 | | Dolly Swift | ATD #824 | MLD #82 |
At least we're agreed about an ATD-level defense 
If you're curious about the forwards, here are the ATD placements (in order) from 2010 and 2011. Winston-Salem players in bold, Medicine Hat players in italics.
ATD 2010: Dornhoefer (545), Nilsson (617), Burns (715), Horvath (720)
ATD 2011: Nilsson (468), Dornhoefer (557), Burns (641), Kerr (748), Horvath (806), Scanlan (838), Bernier (895), Kehoe (938), Juneau (1000) Henning (1003)
In ATD terms, my team enjoys just a slight advantage. |
I'm sure I'm not the only one who thinks that arguing based on past fantasy draft position isn't really an argument at all.