View Single Post
12-06-2003, 05:56 PM
Join Date: Feb 2002
Take of the homerist glasses. You're the only one that thinks McDonald is superior to Parrish. The age argument is nothing because they're the same age. The salary aspect doesn't hold a whole lot of weight considering Parrish has proven he can produce which is going to mean a bigger contract while McDonald hasn't. Good thing Murray doesn't think like you because he would be fired if he didn't take a Parrish for McDonald deal. Yes, McDonald is playing decent but that is an upgrade. Pahlsson and a 3rd for Parrish, that's laughable. A 4th line forward and a decent pick for a 25+ goal man. Ya, that's gonna happen.
You would take McDonald over Parrish, fair enough, but then you go and say you wouldn't give up McDonald to get Comrie. Geez man. Good to see you want your Ducks to get better. If you aren't willing to give up McDonald to get Comrie then you are seriously overrating him my friend. He's a marginal 2nd liner at best, nothing more. You seem to think he's got 1st line written all over him which just isn't the case.
And as for Giguere (who's name is Jean-SEBASTIEN Giguere, if you're going to rip someone for spelling a name wrong then maybe you should get it right), at this point he is a one year wonder. Yes, he's been solid in the regular season but that's it. After the playoffs everyone was calling this guy Patrick Roy. There were alot of people out there that knew he hadn't proven anything yet, and it's showing this year. Gerber has outplayed him to this point.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Kritty