View Single Post
Old
10-29-2012, 11:44 PM
  #310
diceman934
Registered User
 
diceman934's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: NHL player factory
Posts: 6,593
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krazy View Post
Even more simply: (ignoring the brutal logic that a completely different teams would have identical results)

Tank Burke
Kadri Kadri
Seguin Kessel
Knight Colborne
Hamilton Gardiner
Reilly Reilly.

So on the simplest level we traded Seguin, Hamilton, Knight for Kessel, Gardiner, Colborne

That is at least even, if not I could easily see toronto winning that one. Add in Ashton, Percy, Biggs, as prospects and Phaneuf/Lupul as forwards we are WELL ahead.

heck you could even argue that Bozak (25) and Mac (26)are much better than the average first rounder anyway.

I dont love all the burke has done (Keeping liles when we have too many pmd, Trading Kubina for Scraps) but for the most part he has done a fantastic job of rebuilding the leafs.

His only crime is not living in dream world where prospects never have slumps, get injured and all develop 2 way games.....
Your simplest terms is seriously flawed.

Tank Burke
Kadri Kadri
Seguin Kessel
Knight Colborne
Hamilton Gardiner
Reilly Reilly.

Here is the reality:

Tank Burke
Kadri Kadri
Seguin Kessel
Knight Colborne
Hamilton Gardiner
Reilly Reilly.
Colborne
Gardiner

Notice the only difference is the Kessel trade. Why you added in the others is strange to me.

Which would you pick now.

diceman934 is offline