View Single Post
11-15-2012, 02:16 PM
Global Moderator
tarheelhockey's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: The Triangle
Country: United States
Posts: 52,251
vCash: 1020
Originally Posted by Zippy316 View Post
I'm not going to go into detail, because you guys probably did that already,
We went into excruciating detail. Season-by-season, playoff-by-playoff. Advanced numbers... home/road splits... the whole nine. It's all conveniently packed into a single thread, Vote 1.

At the end of that thread, 24 people voted. Think about how large a group that is... it's almost the size of the Vezina voting pool. 24 opinions and perspectives, which have proven to be VERY fractured as of Vote 3. And of those 24, not a single one had Brodeur either first or second. Not one person who took the time to weigh all the evidence concluded that he should be #1... even fewer than the number who thought Hasek was in the top-6

It's not that I don't respect your opinion -- TBH, there was a time not long ago when I was seriously thinking that Brodeur was building a solid claim to the throne. But when 24 people actually sift through the portfolios and are unanimous that he's #3 at best you have to take a step back and honestly ask yourself if you've done your due diligence in forming your opinion.

I strongly recommend you take the advice you've been given here to read through Vote 1 at your leisure. It's an eye-opening collection of information, that will leave you pretty well assured that Brodeur is a fantastic career goalie but very clearly not #1 all time. If you don't want to do that, I'm not sure anyone here (or anywhere) can help you find the answers you're looking for.

tarheelhockey is online now   Reply With Quote