Post your top ten players of All-time
View Single Post
11-20-2012, 05:12 PM
Join Date: Jan 2010
Originally Posted by
eva unit zero
Assuming the list starts in 1994-95, it should look more like this (split up by F/D/G, not listed by ability):
Nope Niedermayer/Bourque were better than Pronger since the mid-90s though Pronger's peak was pretty damn good. I'd say he's a tear below and closer to Rob Blake.
What Selanne did since the mid-90s is more impressive than Lindros though Lindros certainly was a more unique player.
And I was only looking at players who were at or near the end of their career originally but you can't put Osgood there. He was a decent goalie on high end teams. I'd put Luongo/Kiprusoff and maybe even a few others like Lundqvist ahead of Osgood. Probably Nabakov too for a time period though his playoff performances make him go down. Certainly if you're making a top 10 then you don't put any 4th goalie on there ahead of a skater from that era. Was a good era for skaters, terrible for goalies outside the big 3.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Elever