MVP Talk (poll updated Dec 12)
View Single Post
11-26-2012, 05:47 PM
Peter the Great
Join Date: Jun 2007
Originally Posted by
What the Faulk
He didn't nail anything.
-Brady has two great TEs in Gronk and Hernandez. Manning has Dreesen and Tamme. Huge edge Brady.
-Brady has Welker and Lloyd. Manning has Decker and
actually makes DT look competent.
-Brady has Stevan Ridley, Manning has a stable of mediocrity.
By the definition of the award MVP, Manning has the edge.
Brady absolutely deserves consideration in the sense that he should be a "finalist", but unless he vastly outperforms Manning the rest of the season, he doesn't deserve it over him.
What do you mean by this? The only thing holding Thomas back were the injuries and mental mistakes. He has the talent to be one of the best WRs in the league and he has shown that this season. Obviously having Manning throwing him the ball helps but he has also helped Manning a lot. IMO, Thomas is better than Welker, Lloyd, and Decker. This isn't just another case of Manning making a WR look good (eg. Collie).
I agree with you about the Manning vs Brady MVP discussion. Manning is doing more with less around him. My vote would go to Manning.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Avs_19