Jonathan Bernier and Joe Pavelski to Toronto
View Single Post
12-04-2012, 10:39 AM
Join Date: Jun 2012
Originally Posted by
Toronto laughs at the very notion of the first one. I'm not saying we won't trade for Bernier, but trading the much more experienced Reimer for Bernier makes no sense. Throwing a 1st on top of that is ludicrous.
As for the Sharks, I just don't see the Leafs willing to pay a substantial enough premium to get one of their centres, unless the Sharks actively decide they want to get rid of one.
The problem with a guy like Pavelski, is that you're not going to get him right now for MacArthur, Kadri, and a 3rd round pick. He's going to cost you a Kulemin, Lupul, or some other asset of substantial importance. If you do the deal for Pavelski, you've created another hole in your lineup, but haven't really filled one in the process. Pavelski's a good centre, no doubt, but he's not a #1... so even if you trade for him, you're still going to be looking for an upgrade in the middle, and as well as having to replace whoever you trade for him.
How do you figure that a) Bernier's upside is much larger than Reimer's, and b) Reimer isn't guaranteed to be a legitimate starter while Bernier is? considering that one of them is a #1 goalie at this point in time, and the other isn't.
I hope the Oilers hire you . You can make guarantees on young developing players . Can you tell my Oilers managers which players are guaranteed not to get injured . With our luck we could use a guarantee ...oh how long is the guarantee good for . I am looking for a 5 year 200 g 200 a 82 games a season . Can you do it ?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by supert