View Single Post
Old
12-04-2012, 05:45 PM
  #578
OrrNumber4
Registered User
 
OrrNumber4's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Country: Switzerland
Posts: 7,857
vCash: 500
Let me try and make it as generous as I can for Lidstrom:

What I did was normalize their PP scoring to a 75% environment. Now, we have fixed for PP ice time, assuming that % does correlate with ice time. Moreover, we are completely ignoring team strength; not factored into an ES or PP calculation. Sorted by adjusted points (1:1 equivalency PP to ES points)

Career
Player $ESP/S $PPP/S Equalized % Total Adj total PP%
Bobby Orr 75 55 43 130 118 96%
Paul Coffey 46 35 34 81 80 78%
Denis Potvin 40 41 36 81 76 86%
Ray Bourque 39 39 34 78 73 87%
Brian Leetch 36 39 34 75 70 87%
Al MacInnis 32 42 37 74 69 86%
Nicklas Lidstrom 33 34 35 67 68 72%
Brad Park 36 32 30 68 66 80%
Phil Housley 35 33 29 68 64 84%
Sergei Zubov 33 34 31 67 64 82%
Guy Lapointe 31 28 33 59 64 64%
Larry Robinson 35 19 29 54 64 49%
Larry Murphy 34 25 29 59 63 65%
Scott Niedermayer 31 26 30 57 61 64%
Rob Blake 30 26 30 56 60 66%
Chris Pronger 27 29 32 56 59 67%
Borje Salming 31 22 27 53 58 62%
Scott Stevens 31 14 26 45 57 40%
J.C. Tremblay 32 22 24 54 56 69%
Chris Chelios 27 20 29 47 56 52%
Zdeno Chara 24 17 30 41 54 42%
Serge Savard 25 9 28 34 53 24%
Jacques Laperriere 26 9 19 35 45 35%
Rod Langway 20 3 23 23 43 10%
Prime
Player $ESP/S $PPP/S Equalized % Total Adj total PP%
Bobby Orr 80 56 44 136 124 96%
Paul Coffey 60 38 34 98 94 83%
Denis Potvin 44 47 37 91 81 95%
Ray Bourque 44 39 33 83 77 89%
Brad Park 46 35 31 81 77 84%
Brian Leetch 40 41 34 81 74 91%
Guy Lapointe 40 34 34 74 74 75%
Nicklas Lidstrom 36 38 37 74 73 78%
Larry Robinson 40 28 32 68 72 66%
Phil Housley 41 35 30 76 71 87%
Larry Murphy 45 28 26 73 71 80%
Borje Salming 41 32 30 73 71 81%
Al MacInnis 34 42 36 76 70 88%
Rob Blake 40 32 30 72 70 79%
Chris Pronger 32 36 38 68 70 72%
Scott Niedermayer 37 33 31 70 68 79%
Zdeno Chara 30 25 31 55 61 60%
Sergei Zubov 29 35 31 64 60 84%
Scott Stevens 31 14 28 45 59 38%
Chris Chelios 30 30 28 60 58 79%
Serge Savard 28 13 29 41 57 34%
J.C. Tremblay 32 22 24 54 56 69%
Jacques Laperriere 26 9 19 35 45 36%
Rod Langway 22 4 21 26 43 14%

He finishes around 7th/8th. On the PP, he is tied for 7th in career and a strong 4th in his prime.


Last edited by OrrNumber4: 12-04-2012 at 06:01 PM.
OrrNumber4 is offline   Reply With Quote