Is length of career a legitimate obstacle when it comes to the the HoF?
View Single Post
12-06-2012, 08:08 PM
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Baxter, MN
Originally Posted by
In all honesty, I know people knock on
but the guy has got to be getting awfully close to a HHOFer even as a goalie with those lofty standards. I mean, two Hart worthy seasons (2004, 2007), two 2nd team all-stars, one trip to the final in 2011 and one game away from a probable Smythe. An Olympic Gold in 2010 and helping with the World Cup win in 2004. Sure he had some shaky goaltending in international play (which I have personally criticized) but he still won. All of that plus the fact that he's been in the league since 1999 and has a ton of wins/shutouts sort of ties into the fact that he has some good longevity. Honestly, the guy has his critics but he's got more hockey in him.
I am not sure what to make of
. Very good results in with the Vezina but so far a substandard postseason resume. Same with
is a no for me, and
has got to get his team into the postseason more than twice.
I guess that leaves Fleury
. Already won a Cup, is only 28, been to another Cup final, was the 3rd stringer on the Olympic team. Finished as high as 9th in Hart voting. He's had some good years and there have been times in the postseason where he's been stellar (was the best Penguin behind Malkin and Crosby in 2009). The knock on him is that he is very much like Mike Vernon. When the Pens win he is a big part of it. When they lose (and they've lost badly) he has been a huge cause - if not the biggest cause - of it. He has some huge "Sportscenter moments" like saving Lidstrom's shot in the waning seconds in 2009, but he's also got that World Junior fiasco in 2004. I don't know how much of that could factor in, but if he wants people to forget his bluffs, he needs more memorable playoff runs.
But who knows, we could be looking at a normal amount of HHOF goalies in the future. Or not. We'll see, but it goes in cycles.
COUGH COUGH COUGH j. quick COUGH COUGH COUGH
View Public Profile
jack mullet's albums
Visit jack mullet's homepage!
Find More Posts by jack mullet