View Single Post
Old
12-09-2012, 04:25 PM
  #94
Big Phil
Registered User
 
Big Phil's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 20,989
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by toob View Post
Yes Modano would never really get to close to that rookie year of Selanne scoring 76 goals even with the same league/team context. And yes even in a similar context as Selanne in the late 90s he isnt scoring at the same levels. So did Selanne peak higher by virtue of his rookie ssn? Yes. And was he a better player in the late 90s than Modano? Most likely yes but not by that much. But while Modano and Selanne were close throughout the late 90s Modano also continued to be all that in the early 00s whereas Selanne got hurt. That has to make up for something.

This was a guy who was seriously held back offensively in Dallas. This isnt like a Colorado situation where Sakic/Forsberg might have to play some decent D. His numbers were held back by a significant amount. What did Modano score in his prime? 80 points avg? I would hazard a guess that he could have gotten 20 points more not playing somewhere like Dallas. You would be right to say that a significant part of his defensive advantage is also conferred by his team context but make no mistake Modano in a more free environment would still be individually better than say Sakic/Forsberg defensively.
You have to also take into consideration their post lockout careers. Modano and Selanne are vastly different. Selanne had a rejuvenation with that lockout while Modano it seemed was never the same player. That is taken into context with me as well. And yes, in the late 1990s I'd have wanted Selanne on my team over Modano. Not by a large amount, but by a clear enough distance.

Big Phil is offline   Reply With Quote