Too much prospect defense
View Single Post
12-22-2012, 04:59 PM
Baile de Los Locos
Join Date: Feb 2002
Originally Posted by
I wanted to make this thread for some time now. This is a prospects section for hf, not an nhl one. I am looking in the schultz thread and than the armia thread and i see certain fanbases "rallying" around prospects. I think the fact that people feel the need to "defend" prospects is starting to take away from these boards, changing prospect threads for most of the important ones. Since most prospects fail to become nhlers it is probably well justified to criticize (without bias) but the threads are being ruined by people who can only see their prospects doing good. I would also, aside from making this point, like to discuss the methodology of analyzing a prospect. Many fans wrongly assume that explict success (stats and honors) in any particular league is a sign that a prospect is doing well. It turns out that being the highest scoring ohl'er cannot guarantee being above an ahl scrub, let alone a star. Success in those leagues will correllate with players who are going to continue to do well against opposition but this is a weak correlation. Only the very best top scorers make it to the nhl, everyone else is some sort of role player who is selected and eventually makes the nhl on a specific skill set, not on "overall" ability. Thanks for listening to my concen hopefully we can improve the methodology of prospect analysis and make hfboards a legit place where maybe scouts can chill some day. Ps, major pet peeve, these absolutely inane discussions about whether so and so player is canadian or american. Earth to posters it is a totally personal decision that may or may not deal with variables you may not even concieve of.
I agree. But, just a pointer. Use paragraphs so that people can read each point, almost like a newspaper. Most people on this site(and in general) see a wall of words and just reply to the topic head. Just some advice.
I think another major problem is that most people on the prospects board are just fans and will post to defend anything their team does/drafts/transacts, etc.
A lot of opinions on this site happen to be from people that either dont follow other prospects, or team bias.
View Public Profile
Vatican Roulette's albums
Find More Posts by Vatican Roulette