Thread: Post-Game Talk: WJC U20 Championship Game
View Single Post
01-02-2013, 10:34 AM
Registered User
Barnaby's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Port Jefferson, NY
Country: United States
Posts: 4,782
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by JCresty View Post
First off, edit because I think you're challenging because you think I'm referring to past seasons to include the 11/12 season and I guess it can be read and inferred as that. I implied seasons prior to the last season.

First off, i was referring to highlights from past seasons as in seasons before last year which we can all assume needs no further detailing. I didn't say anything about an effective Dubinsky from the 11/12 season. If anything, I said what you're saying now about his let down performance in the 11/12 season. I said he was one of our most effective players in consistently creating offense and being effective, on or off the scoreboard before last season. Aside from Gaborik, Dubinsky was probably our 2nd or 3rd most dominant player in terms of being able to not only score goals and make plays but also cycle and grind in the offensive zone. Even when he was off the score board in the seasons before the 11/12 season, he would still be consistent with playing with an edge and making thing happen more so than a majority of our players in those seasons in terms of both consistently doing so and in terms of impact.

I didn't really get into the transitioning of game plan and obviously a higher calibre player than Dubinksy Backs a more durable and offensively potent game plan. I'm not much of a dubie fan, not as much as a lot of other people on HFNYR so I'm not arguing somr ludicrous point in favor of him. The disappearance of Dubinsky was a detriment and a huge let down because of what is expected from him. Having that said, before the 11/12 season, he was a solid all around player who was consistent with various aspects of play A majority of the time even when he's not producing on the scoresheet. That's all.

You asked me how he was effective and threw a rhetorical "because you say so?" Question to boot. How wasn't he effective in his seasons before 11/12?

Hell, he wasn't completely ineffective last season either. He still executed on certain aspects, scored some goals playing on a demoted line and without PP minutes. He wasn't a defensive liability or guilty of bad turn overs, penalties and lackluster efforts.
I think Dubinsky will be one of those guys who plays very good hockey on a mediocre team as one of the leaders.. I could see him tossing up 50 points with solid two-way play getting top 6 minutes with Columbus. I just think he's passed the point of doing that here. He wouldn't do that as a complimentary piece on this team. He also makes too much $ to stick around as that complimentary piece. I really believe he'll take a step forward in the right direction this year. With that said, this trade gives the Rangers the scorer that they truly needed... the scorer Dubi will never be.

Barnaby is offline   Reply With Quote