Thread: Value of: Scott Harrington
View Single Post
01-06-2013, 03:16 AM
Tender Rip
No cap on coaching!
Tender Rip's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Shanghai, China
Posts: 12,293
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Rowdy Roddy Peeper View Post
It's not about Harrington's value in a vacuum though, TR.

It's the value of arguably the best defensive defense prospect in the world to a team that got its doors blown off in its own end last year and is consequently looking to make a major blueline overhaul within the next couple years.

It would take a helluva lot to make me part with him, for those very reasons.
Arguably the best defensive defense prospect in the world?
This is exactly what I mean. Rob Scuderi looked to be our best defensive defenseman when we won the cup, but it doesn't mean he had great tradevalue even if he hadn't been an UFA, nor does it mean that you cannot trade for reliable ready-mades to fulfill such duties. Scott Harrington had a spectacular coming out year last season and is continuing in that vein as a defensive specialist. That is great, but before he does his thing in the NHL, no one knows that he can be dominant there. As you can never consider him to have offensive upside, that says he is looking good to be a 3rd pairing D-man and PK'er in the NHL down the line.

As for his importance to our team, we didn't get our doors blown off because we had worthless D-men, but because we played worthless defense and had a goalie who made no key saves.

Vaunted Team Canada just gave up 11 goals in two games with nothing but highly rated D-men. Harrington was part of that, by no means the biggest culprit, but he was part of it. Doesn't mean Canada didn't have a kick ass roster - defensively as well. They just didn't perform when they had to - much like the Pens D against Philly. Harrington - like many out and out defenders - didn't fall as hard the others also because he isn't on the ice to take chances.

If we are REALLY lucky, Harington will be a player in mould of a Marc Eduard Vlasic. And for him to be that, he will need to improve quite a bit, and to beat out guys like Despres, Morrow and Dumoulin, not to mention Strait and Bortuzzo in the short term, for an NHL spot, it could take a while.... for a team that surely doesn't need ALL of its D (and Kris Letang) to be made up of guys who are wet behind the ears NHL wise.

You cannot win in the NHL with a bunch of early 20 somethings on D. It just doesn't happen. If we add two of our present stable of D-prospects over the next three years, that will be huge, and with our D-pipeline we are surely not going to fret trading a player who is most likely half a decade from progressing to a spot above the third pairing. At least we shouldn't.

Last edited by Tender Rip: 01-06-2013 at 03:35 AM.
Tender Rip is offline   Reply With Quote