AAA 2012 Division Semis: Pittsburgh Professionals vs. Eisbaren Berlin
View Single Post
01-09-2013, 12:52 PM
Bring Back Scuderi
Join Date: Sep 2009
'68 CHI 56 GP - 12.634, 2.085 PK / 5
'70 MIN 66 GP - 23.283, 0.215 PP, 1.426 PK / 3
'71 MIN 73 GP - 25.367, .600 PP, 2.496 PK / 2
'72 MIN 78 GP - 25.649, 0.765 PP, 2.594 PK / 2/3
'73 MIN 60 GP - 24.259, 0.501 PP, 1.826 PK / 1/2
'74 MIN 76 GP - 25.296, 0.343 PP, 3.264 PK / 2
'75 MIN 74 GP - 23.827, 0.140 PP, 3.069 PK / 2
'76 MIN 69 GP - 22.769, 3.204 PP, 2.925 PK / 4
'77 MIN 65 GP - 22.190, 0.545 PP, 2.556 PK / 4
Weighted TOI Average: 14981.932 / 653 GP = 22.943 minutes per game
ES TOI Team Ranks: 1/2, 2, 2, 2, 2/3, 3, 4, 4, 5
'96 LAK 53 GP - 20.628, 3.796 PP, 1.923 PK / 5
'97 LAK 60 GP - 21.044, 2.746 PP, 1.680 PK / 3
'98 LAK 45 GP - 18.390, 2.340 PP, 1.190 PK / 4
'99 LAK 45 GP - 17.840, 2.410 PP, 0.530 PK / 5
'02 LAK 80 GP - 21.590, 2.880, 2.240 PK / 3
'03 DAL 80 GP - 20.490, 1.880 PP, 2.480 PK / 3
'04 DAL 70 GP - 22.410, 2.160 PP, 2.680 PK / 2
'06 DAL 66 GP - 23.410, 4.770 PP, 4.050 PK / 2
'07 DAL 76 GP - 22:53, 4:05 PP, 3:01 PK / 3 1,740:20
Weighted TOI Averages: 15476.544 / 748 = 20.691 minutes per game
ES TOI Team Ranks: 2, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4, 5, 5
Getting a feel for how these pairs compare is more difficult. I like Lamoureux and his all-star record is very appealing at this level, but it does seem bothersome that his career coincided with the war years. His 3 seasons of all-star votes were '44, '45, and '46.
Levinsky I'm even less sold on. Nice that he part of two cup winners like Lamoureux, but I have no idea how important he was to those teams. He has great longevity for his era and received a single all-star vote once but that's all I've got. If he had some anecdotal support, like I found for Bowman, that would help clear things up.
Boucher's a much more known commodity. He showed up in all-star voting once placing 14th in 2007 when he scored 19 goals. I think he rose to a level of defensive responsibility in his Dallas days, PKing under Tippet, that gives him an advantage over the Berards of this draft.
I think Reid or Lamoureux are probably the best defender of this group. Based on the war years, I think a case can be made for Reid. Reid had basically no offensive game, but his defense was good enough to tie for 10th place in 72's all-star voting. He averaged more estimated TOI over his career than Brown or Smith and essentially never saw a powerplay in his career. I don't think many other defense-only guys can claim a similar voting record, even with it being just one season.
Lamoureux brings good offense without sacrificing defense and brings a physical game. Levinsky seems to be a conservative type who could skate and hit. You definitely have the physical edge here. Boucher is my best offensive defender mentioned thus far and is on Manery's level PP-wise. I think his defense is passable here as well. Reid is there to shore that up and while he isn't going to wow anyone with the puck on his stick, I think he and Boucher fit each other very well.
I want to claim an advantage here, but doing so is mostly because I'm not sold on Levinsky. I like Reid here a lot. I was very high on Lamoureux coming into the draft but the war year concern does loom. I still think he's better than Boucher, but I'm sort of giving him the benefit of the doubt and putting a lot of stock in war year all-star votes in doing so. I mean his career basically started and ended when the war years did. I'm less willing to do the same with Levinsky until I learn more. Unless Levinsky was more than a role player on those teams I see the edge of Reid over him as the swing in Pittsburgh's favor here.
Bring Back Scuderi
View Public Profile
Bring Back Scuderi's albums
Find More Posts by Bring Back Scuderi