View Single Post
Old
01-10-2013, 10:59 AM
  #84
Lebda Snipes
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Maple Leaf Gardens
Country: Canada
Posts: 134
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by 416Leafer View Post
I'm not saying he's not our best centre. Or that compared to the league average he's not a good #2.

I just hear too many people say he's a "very good second line centre". But the real benchmark in these types of comparisons SHOULD be SC Champions.

It's like the debates for #1 Defenceman. Some people consider any D who is top 30 in the league to be a #1 D. Personally I would say an average #1 D is the average out of the top D from SC Champion teams. Aka the average out of Doughty, Chara, Keith, Gonchar, Lidstrom, Niedermayer, etc.

Because if you're comparing yourself to the average from SC Champions, if a player in any position is below the average for recent SC winners, then that player is actually a negative when considering a battle for the SC, even if theyre better then the league average.

At least that's how I assess players/team building. SC Champions should be the benchmark, otherwise what you're aiming for might be good enough for playoffs, but not necessarily to win it all.

Grabo can provide some good secondary scoring and is pretty competent two-ways.. but not good enough to even play on the PK, one of the worst PKs in the league mind you. It's more that he just doesn't regularly cough the puck up and back-checks. Admirable qualities and definitely good things, but it's not like he's a defensive machine or at all close to Selke calibre. ~55 points from your 2nd C who doesn't play on the PK isn't anything to write home about.
Agreed he had lack luster season last year, after coming off a steller one the season before. But the skill is there, and his overall play was solid.

And he is a player that i would like to see on the PK, as i think he would help our PK struggles. But i think the only reason he doesnt play on the PK is because he play too many minutes 5 on 5 and PP, not becasue he is not good enough. Under Burke he structured us the same way he structures all his teams. Top 6 players to score and play PP. Bottom six to play energy/checking roles and to play PK and sheltered situational minutes. Maybe Carlyle will try him out on the PK casue it seems like a match made in heaven given his skill set.

Lebda Snipes is offline   Reply With Quote