2014 - Canada Roster Discussion (Part III)
View Single Post
01-16-2013, 12:02 PM
Join Date: Apr 2010
Originally Posted by
I have no real issues with your 1st team except for Perry. First of all, he's not a great skater, 2nd of all he's prone to taking too many idiotic penalties, and as a 13th forward he is only a winger. I suggest a more versatile player who can play either center or on the wing, is not a brain cramp away from costing us a game against Switzerland or Slovakia and a player who can get around on the big ice. We don't need Perry's experience or his 30 goals, we have tonnes of players to fill that roll. One player better suited for the 13th forward is J. Staal, although a similar skating style to Perry, at least he's good at center or on the wing and takes few penalties.
Perry is there to fill a role, similar to what 86Habs suggested. Canada doesn't need to take another centre as the 13th forward, as you will note there are 8 centres on the team I listed already. Skating is somewhat troublesome, but it isn't as if it's a weakness for the team overall. Perry brings a grinding element to the team that is lacking in almost all of the forwards, a willingness to go to the dirtiest areas on the ice and also the experience to do damage from those areas. I'm not especially worried about penalties either, as I see Perry have a very specialized role with emphasis on avoiding penalty trouble. I've seen Perry toe the line enough in the playoffs and Olympics to have optimism, even if this is in Europe.
I have some worries about this team having too many players who are accustomed to dominating the puck in the offensive zone. Perry offers some flexibility there as well, as he scores lots of goals but does do without being the primary puck possessor on his line. Perry is also a guy I can see excelling in spot PP duty as a net presence, which won't be a strong suit for many of the stars on the team. I just like what Perry can bring to this team, it's something different from what everyone else offers. Canada has often had success bringing this kind of player to international competitions. Those were often Canada Cups on NA size ice, but I definitely see lots of benefit to bringing one Perry type player for the sake of team flexibility.
I would think that Benn meets your own criteria more than J. Staal, who is pretty redundant if Toews, Bergeron and M. Richards are all on the team. I don't know if any player is ideal in the 13th forward role, as much depends on what who the 12 other forwards are.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by JackSlater