View Single Post
01-17-2013, 11:28 AM
Registered User
SOLR's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Toronto / North York
Country: Canada
Posts: 4,877
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by DAChampion View Post
Let's say hypothetically we trade Plekanec, Markov, and Cole, for three 1st rounders, leaving aside the fact that we could probably do better on the trade market.

We're not getting Max Pacioretty 3 times, and we're not getting Terry Ryan 3 times. Looking at the Timmins-era 1st rounders, we'd get:

Andrei Kostitsyn, 10th overall
Kyle Chipchura, 18th overall
Carey Price, 5th overall
David Fischer, 20th Overall
Ryan McDonagh, 12th overall
Max Pacioretty, 22nd overall

Louis Leblanc, 18th overall
Jarrod Tinordi, 22nd overall
Nathan Beaulieu, 17th overall
Alex Galchenyuk, 3rd overall

Out of the six players for which we have had enough time to evaluate, we see three fantastic NHLers (50%) who are on par with Plekanec,Cole, and Markov; a 2nd liner who is a step down (Andrei Kostitsyn) and two busts (Fischer and Chipchura).

Thus, if we trade Plekanec, Cole, and Markov, the most likely outcome is to get 2 NHLers, either 2 very good ones or one very good one and one decent one, with one bust. That's a decent return. We'll also have cleared 15.25 million worth of cap space, giving us the means to make noise on the UFA market and upgrade. And again, this leaves aside the fact that I think we could do better than 3 1st rounders.
There is only 1 bust, Fischer, we went for a Homerun on that one. Chipchura has never reached his potential but played in the NHL quite a bit, he was in a ok pick in a below average draft. We haven't seen years like 2004 and 2006 in talent quality since then, not sure there are some in our future mostly because of how much the sport is growing in the US. The prospect pool will never be that weak ever again.

SOLR is offline