View Single Post
Old
01-20-2013, 03:53 AM
  #1
saskriders
Can't Hold Leads
 
saskriders's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Auckland
Country: New Zealand
Posts: 21,932
vCash: 750
How would you rank the Oilers dynasty players

Combination of good, and biggest impact, the weighting, and definitions of "impact" and "good" are up to you, as long as it only counts time in Edmonton. So no Rangers Messier, or Kings Gretzky.

To draw a line somewhere let's say 3 cups in Edmonton grantees you a spot (they are all on my list, so no need for research), but if you have 2 cup wins and played a big enough roll you can be on the list too

As someone who wasn't alive at the time, and is just speculating, and will probably be way off. But I am interested in seeing you opinions

#1: Gretzky
#2: Messier
#3: Coffey
#4: Kurri
#5: Anderson
#6: Fuhr
#7: Lowe
#8: Tikkanen

this is where there is a big gap and it gets really tricky, especially for someone who wasn't around at the time. So these could be terrible, especially since I have never even heard of the last 6. Just sorted them based on how cool their name is

#9: Moog
#10: Mactavish
#11: Huddy
#12: Smith
#13:Semenko
#14:McSorley
#15:Krushelnyski
#16: Beukuboom
#17: Pouzar
#18: Muni
#19: Hunter
#20: McClelland
#21: Gregg

saskriders is offline   Reply With Quote