View Single Post
Old
01-22-2013, 06:09 PM
  #611
BM67
Registered User
 
BM67's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: In "The System"
Country: Canada
Posts: 4,573
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by BM67 View Post
Shore Of Boston Picked As Outstanding Star

2 Canadiens Make All-Star NHL Six

Found almost complete voting for the first official NHL All-Star teams in 1930-31. It is missing 7 votes for the alternate team defense, 3 of which belong to Shore, so we need only 4 more. The 7 missing points and the one for McVicar are also not assigned to left or right defense.

There is also no mention of the coaches, so I'm not sure when or how they were voted for.

ALL-STAR TEAMS: 37 voters, 1st and 2nd format
GOALTENDER: FIRST TEAM: Charlie Gardiner, Chi 16; Tiny Thompson, Bos 10; Roy Worters, NYA 9; George Hainsworth, Mtl 1; John Roach, NYR 1
ALTERNATE TEAM: Charlie Gardiner, Chi 13; Tiny Thompson, Bos 9; Roy Worters, NYA 9; George Hainsworth, Mtl 4; Lorne Chabot, Tor 2
DEFENSE: FIRST TEAM: (Right 37, Left 37) Eddie Shore, Bos 34 (Right 27, Left 7); King Clancy, Tor 22 (Right 5, Left 17); Sylvio Mantha, Mtl 8 (Right 2, Left 6); Ching Johnson, NYR 3 (Left 3); Red Dutton, NYA 2 (Right 2); Lionel Hitchman, Bos 2 (Right 1, Left 1); Ted Graham, Chi 2 (Left 2); Hap Day, Tor 1 (Left 1)
ALTERNATE TEAM: (Right 32, Left 34, unknown 4) Sylvio Mantha, Mtl 17 (Right 11, Left 6); Ching Johnson, NYR 13 (Right 5, Left 8); Lionel Hitchman, Bos 8 (Left 8); King Clancy, Tor 8 (Right 7, Left 1); Red Dutton, NYA 8 (Right 5, Left 3); Eddie Shore, Bos 3; George Owen, Bos 3 (Right 2, Left 1); Hap Day, Tor 3 (Right 1, Left 2); Ted Graham, Chi 2 (Left 2); Cy Wentworth, Chi 2 (Left 2); Taffy Abel, Chi 2 (Right 1, Left 1); Jack McVicar, Mtl 1 (4 votes missing)
CENTER: FIRST TEAM: Howie Morenz, Mtl 29; Joe Primeau, Tor 2; Frank Boucher, NYR 2; Ebbie Goodfellow, Det 2; Cooney Weiland, Bos 1; Aurel Joliat, Mtl 1
ALTERNATE TEAM: Frank Boucher, NYR 11; Ebbie Goodfellow, Det 8; Nels Stewart, Mtl M 6; Howie Morenz, Mtl 6; Cooney Weiland, Bos 3; Tom Cook, Chi 2; Joe Lamb, Ott 1
RIGHT WING: FIRST TEAM: Bill Cook, NYR 26; Dit Clapper, Bos 4; Charlie Conacher, Tor 3; Johnny Gottselig, Chi 2; Hooley Smith, Mtl M 1; Frank Finnigan, Ott 1
ALTERNATE TEAM: Dit Clapper, Bos 12; Charlie Conacher, Tor 7; Bill Cook, NYR 5; Ace Bailey, Tor 3; Hooley Smith, Mtl M 3; Howie Morenz, Mtl 1; Ebbie Goodfellow, Det 1; Johnny Gagnon, Mtl 1; Nels Stewart, Mtl M 1; Harry Oliver, Bos 1; John Sorrell, Det 1; Jimmy Ward, Mtl M 1
LEFT WING: FIRST TEAM: Aurel Joliat, Mtl 22; Bun Cook, NYR 4; Nels Stewart, Mtl M 2; Babe Siebert, Mtl M 2; Jimmy Ward, Mtl M 1; Harry Oliver, Bos 1; Johnny Gagnon, Mtl 1; Dutch Gainor, Bos 1; Ebbie Goodfellow, Det 1; Mush March, Chi 1; Busher Jackson, Tor 1
ALTERNATE TEAM: Bun Cook, NYR 12; Johnny Gottselig, Chi 5; Hec Kilrea, Ott 4; Busher Jackson, Tor 4; Aurel Joliat, Mtl 3; Nels Stewart, Mtl M 3; Bill Cook, NYR 2; Dit Clapper, Bos 2; Howie Morenz, Mtl 1; Marty Barry, Bos 1

COACH: Lester Patrick, NYR; Dick Irvin, Chi
Found the 4 missing 2nd team votes on D. 1 more for George Owen and 3 for Reg Noble.

Also added some more names to the Hart and Lady Byng results, but without voting totals.

1930-31
1- M.J. Rodden, Toronto Globe
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Johnson, Rangers, right defense; Noble, Detroit, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Bailey, Toronto, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
2- E.W. Ferguson, Montreal Herald
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Day, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
3- James Gallagher, Chicago Evening American
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Oliver, Boston, left wing
Second Team: Hainsworth, Canadiens, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Graham, Chicago, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; H. Smith, Maroons, right wing; Gottselig, Chicago, left wing
4- W.A. Hewitt, Toronto Star
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Chabot, Toronto, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Day, Toronto, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
5- W.J. Morrison, Montreal Gazette
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; H. Smith, Maroons, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Hainsworth, Canadiens, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
6- Ed Baker, Ottawa Citizen
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
7- Edwin Allan, Toronto Mail and Empire
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Weiland, Boston, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
8- Leonard Cohen, New York Evening Post
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Chabot, Toronto, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Oliver, Boston, left wing
9- A.J. Morganson, Toronto Telegram
First Team: Hainsworth, Canadiens, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Dutton, Americans, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Kilrea, Ottawa, left wing
10- Patrick Robinson, New York Daily News
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Joliat, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Siebert, Maroons, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Morenz, Canadiens, right wing; Gottselig, Chicago, left wing
11- Burt Whitman, Boston Herald
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Day, Toronto, left defense; Lamb, Ottawa, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Gottselig, Chicago, left wing
12- Albert Laberge, Montreal La Presse
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
13- Robert T. Paul, Philadelphia Daily News
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Primeau, Toronto, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Johnson, Rangers, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Goodfellow, Detroit, right wing; Morenz, Canadiens, left wing
14- Joe Vila, New York Sun
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
15- Peter Kelley, Boston Daily Record
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Weiland, Boston, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Gagnon, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Abel, Chicago, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
16- Eddie O’Meara, Ottawa Journal
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Johnson, Rangers, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
17- William Grimes, Boston American
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Finnigan, Ottawa, right wing; Gainor, Boston, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; McVicar, Maroons, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Kilrea, Ottawa, left wing
18- William Farnsworth, New York Evening Journal
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Dutton, Americans, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Jackson, Toronto, left wing
19- Roland Beaudry, Montreal La Canada
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Weiland, Boston, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
20- A. Horwits, Philadelphia Evening Ledger
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Primeau, Toronto, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Abel, Chicago, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto. right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
21- H.E. Narbonne, Montreal Le Devoir
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Johnson, Rangers, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; Bailey, Toronto, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
22- F.J. Carveth, Detroit Free Press
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Johnson, Rangers, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; Jackson, Toronto, left wing
23- Dee Sparr, Chicago Daily Times
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Graham, Chicago, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Gottselig; Chicago, right wing; Goodfellow, Detroit, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Wentworth, Chicago, left defense; T. Cook, Chicago, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
24- Horace Lavigne, Montreal La Patrie
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Gagnon, Canadiens, right wing; Gottselig, Chicago, left wing
25- Howard G. Rayner, Boston Post
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Owen, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; H. Smith, Maroons, right wing; Barry, Boston, left wing
26- Gil. O. Julien, Ottawa Le Droit
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
27- Joe Williams, New York Telegram
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Hitchman, Boston, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; March, Chicago, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; Conacher, Toronto, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
28- Wade R. Franklin, Chicago Daily Press
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Siebert, Maroons, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Graham, Chicago, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; Bailey, Toronto, right wing; Gottselig, Chicago, left wing
29- A.W. Daley, New York World
First Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Jackson, Toronto, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Day, Toronto, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; Oliver, Boston, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
30- Ray Bousloy, Detroit Daily News
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Noble, Detroit, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; H. Smith, Maroons, right wing; Clapper, Boston, left wing
31- Joseph C. Nichols, New York Times
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Owen, Boston, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Sorrell, Detroit, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
32- Lloyd Northard, Detroit News
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Stewart, Maroons, left wing
Second Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Wentworth, Chicago, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Jackson, Toronto, left wing
33- George M.R. Holmes, Boston Christian Science Monitor
First Team: Roach, Rangers, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Owen, Boston, right defense; Hitchman, Boston, left defense; Goodfellow, Detroit, center; Ward, Maroons, right wing; Kilrea, Ottawa, left wing
34- James Hurley, New York Daily Mirror
First Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Hainsworth, Canadiens, goal; Dutton, Americans, right defense; Johnson, Rangers, left defense; Boucher, Rangers, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Kilrea, Ottawa, left wing
35- J.P. Carmichael, Chicago Herald and Examiner
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Graham, Chicago, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; Gottselig, Chicago, right wing; Ward, Maroons, left wing
Second Team: Thompson, Boston, goal; Owen, Boston, right defense; S Mantha, Canadiens, left defense; T. Cook, Chicago, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
36- J.C. Zinck, Chicago Evening Post
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Clancy, Toronto, right defense; Shore, Boston, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Worters, Americans, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Noble, Detroit, left defense; Stewart, Maroons, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; F. Cook, Rangers, left wing
37- Floyd Taylor, New York Herald Tribune
First Team: Gardiner, Chicago, goal; Shore, Boston, right defense; Clancy, Toronto, left defense; Morenz, Canadiens, center; W. Cook; Rangers, right wing; Joliat, Canadiens, left wing
Second Team: Hainsworth, Canadiens, goal; S Mantha, Canadiens, right defense; Dutton, Americans, left defense; Weiland, Boston, center; Clapper, Boston, right wing; Jackson, Toronto, left wing

BM67 is offline   Reply With Quote