HOH Top-40 Goalies Voter Record - Canadiens1958
View Single Post
02-08-2013, 10:30 PM
Join Date: Dec 2007
Originally Posted by
Your presentation is based on a number of assumptions and pulls data from different eras.
Hasek played in the NHL from 1990 thru the dead puck era thru 2007-08. Your rebound data is from the 2007-08 era and does not reflect how the game was played pre the 2004-05 lockout. Rules changed significantly post lockout. The 2 second allowance is very generous for rebound goal since it covers the complete offensive zone as opposed to the slot.
You are operating under three assumptions that have not been vetted or supported.
1.) that the other goalies on Hasek's team were better than him in terms of rebound control. If you look at his teammates, only two were within 30 spots of him in this project - Belfour and Fuhr. No claim has been made that Belfour and/or Fuhr were better than Hasek in terms of rebound control. In Buffalo, after Fuhr was traded Hasek's back-ups were rookies - Biron or career minor league veterans - Shields, Roloson. Weaker rebound control in all instances.
2.) assuming that the data vs 1990 back-ups has meaning in terms of comparisons against other goalies vying for the top 40 spots and who retired before 1990. The only meaning it may have is in comparison to Roy and Brodeur. But you did not produce the numbers for Roy and Brodeur. Compare Hasek's numbers vs Brodeur and you will see the rebound control difference.Then watch game films to compare the statistical with the visual.
Brodeur is the only goalie from the post 1990 era whose rebound control would compare with the pre 1990 goalies.
3.) your data would be interesting if it factored in the opposition. Are you assuming that against Hasek the opposition had more or fewer shoots, than against the rest of the league teams.
Interesting but far from complete.
Rebound control isn't too difficult when a goalie only faces 4 or 5 tough chances a game.
View Public Profile
Dennis Bonvie's albums
Find More Posts by Dennis Bonvie