View Single Post
02-11-2013, 02:40 PM
Kershaw's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 25,511
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Machinehead View Post
Point production over the last 3 years

Horcoff: 39
Dubinsky: 44
Stoll: 37
Hansen: 31
Steen: 50 (not sure why you included him, he's very clearly a top 6 player)

Callahan: 46
Goals over the last 3 years:

Horcoff: 14
Dubinsky: 18
Stoll: 14
Hansen: 14
Steen: 24

Callahan: 26

So as you see here, Callahan is clearly a better point producer than everyone except Dubinsky who is arguably a top 6 player, and Steen who is without a doubt. And he's a vastly superior goal scorer to everyone there, again except Steen who is indisputably imo a top 6 scorer.

**Some stats are adjusted for injuries.
I'm only talking in terms of hockey skill in terms of shot, skating, passing, vision, which is where Callahan belongs in this group. Also Steen plays behind Backes and Berglund as 3C. Horcoff and Stoll also both had 65+ pt seasons each once in their careers, but neither hit it consistently. I doubt Callahan ever hits 60 pts in his career, too much of a grinder to do so.

Kershaw is offline