Time to make Moves?? (Post trade proposals & rumors here)
View Single Post
02-13-2013, 10:12 PM
Join Date: Feb 2002
Originally Posted by
Yashin for President
Ryan is exactly what we need. Please end this talk of O'Reilly because he wants just as much as JT makes or more. What someone else said, Garth would look stupid if they did that. Could have signed PA for 4 million. Back to Ryan, he would make us so much better. We would finally have a legit 1st line.
i can't possibly disagree more. snow would not look stupid for losing parenteau but trading for o'reilly. they are two completely different players. i see o'reilly like mike peca. the isles could use a little more heart and soul. peca brought that. o'reilly would.
and, of course, i agree that bobby ryan would make the nyi better. but is he available? o'reilly is. would he win more games for the nyi than o'reilly would? i say no. they are two different players and they each impact the game in their own way. my belief is players like o'reilly impact the game on a more consistent basis than players like bobby ryan.
just one man's opinion.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by islandermaniac