Trade Rumours and Proposals: Part XXXV
View Single Post
02-21-2013, 08:59 AM
Join Date: Apr 2011
Originally Posted by
I think you have to be realsitic about expectations. Silfverberg doesn't have Zibanejad's draft pedigree, but he has developed leaps and bounds since the draft. Even in his draft year he was viewed as a potential star, but there were a lot of questions. He gets better every year and he has shown the ability to dominate at various levels. (SEL -> AHL) He just takes time and is a slow starter (even in his MVP season last year he started pretty slowly). Every game you watch Silfverberg with Ottawa you can see that he is improving and catching onto things.
The biggest issue I have with Zibanejad is that I don't see improvement -- even from last year he looks like essentially the same player. I know he's had injury issues and problems, but I just don't see the elite upside in Zibanejad. He has never dominated any level of hockey (even the WJC...golden goal aside...he was outplayed by a lot of younger players where he should have had a big physical advantage).
Personally I don't think that Zibanejad has higher upside than a 2nd line winger. Maybe that's just me. If you can provide some kind of evidence that points elsewhere besides 'he has nice tools' that would really be encouraging.
I'm much more optimistic about our 1st round pick last year in Ceci. I think last year was just not a good draft year for us.
Second line would be great IMO I'd be really happy. My point isn't that he's amazing it actually kind of coincides with what your saying.
Basically he hasn't been developing very well and has struggled through some bad head injuries.
We need to put him in the A like we did with all our prospects and leave him their until he starts getting better. It's becoming obvious that he is a bit of a project with good upside and should be treated as such.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by BK201