Have 09/10 BlackHawks had the deepest roster ever?
View Single Post
02-21-2013, 04:46 PM
Join Date: Jul 2011
Originally Posted by
Because they lost their starting goaltender and best skater for one month.
The same month
During the injuries to Giguere and Pronger: 2-7-2; -9 goal differential
During the rest of the regular season: 46-13-12; +59 goal differential
That's why they beat the team with the highest goal differential (Ottawa +66; which was lower than Anaheim's pace with Pronger/Giguere) in five games, proving that writing them off historically because of goal differential is a little silly.
Let's not pretend that none of the other teams in contention for this didn't suffer injuries. Anaheim lost a month of Pronger and Giguere, so what? Just from the same year, Ottawa lost comparable amounts of time from each of Spezza, Fisher, and Redden. Buffalo lost Tallinder for half the year, along with injuries to other important players like Lydman and Afinogenov. For Detroit it was Zetterberg, Kronwall, Schneider...
If the Ducks were half as deep as people claimed them to be, one would argue that losing two players (even ones as important as Giguere or Pronger) would not have significantly impaired them.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by GuineaPig