ATD 2013 Lineup Advice Thread
View Single Post
02-27-2013, 05:22 PM
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Originally Posted by
Was wondering how to put my powerplay, this is what I'm thinking right now but it's subject to change:
PP 1: Denneny-Clarke-Bondra-Oates-Suchy
PP 2: Prentice-Sutter-Gilbert-Hartsburg-Smith
Also for the fun of it here is my PK:
PK 1: Prentice-Clarke-Horton-Horner
PK 2: Sutter-Graham-Suchy-Smith
All opinions are welcomed.
I'm torn on Steve Smith on the PP. If he's next to a guy that's a good pointman, I think he can work but I'm not sure Hartsburg is good enough. Smith basically had 4 good seasons offensively, and then barely did anything besides that. Hartsburg was great when he was on the ice, but he rarely played a full season. Together as a second unit, I guess they work.
The first PP is good, the second unit is lacking punch and a finisher. Brent Sutter shouldn't be on a PP in the ATD, he broke 100 points once when he got a chance to play with Bossy, and never broke 70 points otherwise, despite receiving what looks like 2nd unit PP time on the Islanders. Prentice can work as the clearly 3rd best offensive member of a PP to do the dirty work, but him and Sutter on the same unit are not good. You've got Gilbert, who is a great passer from the wing, and Prentice/Sutter aren't good enough to capitalize on that.
For the PP, I'd use:
That way, you've got two good passers in Gilbert and Clarke to feed Denneny, and your 2nd unit is way more potent with the heavy assist Oates passing to the heavy goal Bondra. Horner was top 9 in points among defensemen 6 times, he and Smith will be pretty weak as PP pointmen, but it can still work.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by BillyShoe1721