Thread: Proposal: Sj - Det
View Single Post
Old
03-02-2013, 06:19 PM
  #6
Macoun
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 76
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by Squeeven View Post
To Detroit:
Ryane Clowe
Douglas Murray
4th round pick in 2013



To San Jose:
Valterri Filppula
6th round pick in 2013




Sharks add some much needed scoring depth and a speedy Center/LW which they deperately need (more so a winger but since he can play both they can always shuffle him around which Mclellan loves to do).

The Wings add some toughness to their lineup to go with Tootoo. Clowe is not a dirty player at all but he's really good at standing up for his teammates and getting them going, plus when he's on his game and he can do some damage offensively. They also add some depth to their defense with Murray, big and tough and can lay down some huge hits, and is great on the penalty kill and great at blocking shots.

I think this is a fair trade but I can see my fellow Sharks fans saying we might be giving up too much and Wings fans saying that's not enough, both of which might be true but I think its fair. What do you guys think?
The wings have a lot of defenseman so the sharks would have to take colaiacovo to make the deal work

Macoun is offline   Reply With Quote