View Single Post
Old
03-16-2013, 02:08 AM
  #205
major major
Registered User
 
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 11,779
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mayor Bee View Post
I figure Tier 1 is only the guys who have a shot at going #1 overall. Jones and MacKinnon have been #1 guys the last 18 months and haven't budged, but I wouldn't be shocked if teams have Drouin #1 internally. I don't think that anyone has Barkov that high.
If that's your criteria, then that works.

I haven't made explicit tiers until now, but my criteria are upside and downside, with a bias towards upside. Hockeysfuture (not the best publication, I know) has a pretty good ranking system to capture upside and downside. This is my guess as to how good these players will be.

Tier 1
Jones 9.5C
Mackinnon 9B
Drouin 9C
Barkov 8.5B

Tier 2
Nichushkin 9D
Lindholm 8.5C
Nurse 8.5C
Monahan 8C

Tier 3
don't know enough about these players

I just found this thread with a lot of their past rankings in it Crosby, JJ, etc..

major major is offline