Blues Trade Proposals Part 4
View Single Post
03-21-2013, 01:27 PM
Join Date: Jan 2011
Originally Posted by
But most of the defensive work comes in the defensive end. In terms of defense percentages
Backes 85% (backchecking, helping the defensemen below the hashmarks and behind the net in the defensive end)
Oshie 15% (backchecking in the neutral zone and very very small amounts in the defensive end)
Oshie's only real defensive credit comes from his backchecking. I don't give Oshie any significant credit for what he does in the defensive end because wingers don't carry much responsibility in that zone, so I don't really think it's fair to give Oshie much defensive credit as a forward because Backes is the one doing all the work.
You can't ignore everything else he does. It is incredibly narrow minded to believe the only good defensive forwards are centers. If it wasn't for Oshie's ability to cause turnovers, the shots we allow would go up, something that our defense gets a lot of credit for.
If he his defense is at he level that you think, then Hitchcock wouldn't make it a point to put him against the tougher competition, and if defense wasn't important for wingers, he wouldn't make it a point to give easier minutes to the forwards that are not as good defensively.
In a concept or theory, yes wingers don't have the same responsibility in the defensive end, but hockey is a 200 foot game.
Using the opposite of your argument, Karlsson is not that valuable because offense isn't that important for a defenseman.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by bleedblue1223