Thread: Proposal: Luongo for Grabovski
View Single Post
03-26-2013, 06:09 PM
Sergei Shirokov
Registered User
Sergei Shirokov's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: British Columbia
Country: Canada
Posts: 8,232
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by kihei View Post
Voodoo logic.

Are you actually suggesting that Luongo has had a better year than Reimer? If you want to talk about current, okay, let's talk current.


Luongo 2.47
Reimer 2.64

Advantage Luongo

Save %

Luongo .904
Reimer .918

Advantage Reimer


Luongo 7-4-3
Reimer 11-4-4

Advantage Reimer

Team improvement in the standings over last year

Vancouver -3
Toronto +7

Advantage Reimer

Defensive Support

Luongo, with the lower save %, plays in front of a top four defense that includes Hamhuis, Edler, Bieksa and Garrison

Reimer, with the higher save %, plays in front of a top four defense that before last week included Phaneuf, Holzer, Gunnarsson, and Kostka

More impressive performance: Reimer

Forget Grabovski. Why would we trade our goaltender straight up for your goaltended, especially when one figures in the difference in age and the horrible contract?

Luongo was an elite goaltender. He isn't that anymore. Currently he is

18 th in GAA
32 nd (tie) in wins
28 th (tie) in save %

You can say what you want about the past, and I'd probably agree with much of it. But this year, based on actual play, Roberto is not one of the top ten goalies in the league, much less elite.

Chris Kunitz is having a better year than everyone in the league except Crosby and Stamkos. So is he better than everyone else in the league aswell?

Troy Brouwer has more goals, and a better +/- in less games than Phil Kessel. Is Brouwer better than Kessel?

Re-read what I said.

"Luongo is better than any of your current options." In the form of a question:

Who is the better goalie. James Riemer or Roberto Luongo. Throw contracts and everything aside. If you are choosing 1 goalie of the 2. Who are you choosing?

Nothing against Riemer. But the choice is obvious. And yes Lu is still elite.

Sergei Shirokov is offline   Reply With Quote