Trade Proposals Thread
View Single Post
04-07-2013, 07:17 AM
Join Date: Jun 2010
Originally Posted by
Not a fan of trading Staal, would hate it tbo.
I think its a better idea of move Girardi even though we lack a right handed shot om the blue line even more. Girardi is a warrior and a iron man but Staal is both younger and the better player of them two.
At this juncture I have no concrete suggestion on trading either Staal or Girardi, neither or both (consider enhanced value as a L-R package deal). The idea was to ask now that the post trade dust has settled, and the trade order is starting to roughly shape up, what returns do we get, whether they are prospects, vets or other assets (picks) that make a deal worthwhile.
This may shock people who have seen me ahead of the curve suggest Girardi as the most moveable of our top (despite he being the only R). But I remain consistent. No sacred cows. But also, no coke for pepsi, no deal just to make a deal. Only move talent, esp. top talent, if the return is worthwhile.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by bernmeister