Game 40 | April 11, 2013 | San Jose Sharks @ Detroit Red Wings (Mod note #692)
View Single Post
04-10-2013, 08:11 PM
Join Date: Jun 2010
Originally Posted by
Has a season to prove what? We're debating the offensive abilities of Justin Abdelkader and Jordin Tootoo. This is Abdelkader's 3rd 'full' season, Tootoo has been in the league for 9 years. There's more reasons to believe that Abdelkader has a better shot at actually being offensively competent than a guy who has a career high of 24 assists (!!!!) in one year.
Regardless, it's a stupid debate and an even stupider premise to think that either guy is a good fit on his line or better fit than the other. Who cares if Tootoo is slightly better, we're still debating if Tootoo or Abdelkader is "better" on a line with Pavel freaking Datsyuk. What's next?
I don't understand the cop out people are taking by exclaiming there is now point in debating who should be on Datsyuk's wing between the two. If Tootoo is better in a lot of areas, it makes sense that between him an Gator, he should be there.
I mean, considering the point of this player is to be a 'big body" and crash and bang, create space, it's actually a really simple answer when you take in the fact that Tootoo, like you pointed out, has more experience, has put up better numbers in a season than Gator, and actually hits hard, he should be there.
Heaven forbid we use statistics to help back up our point! My, oh my! I know this is the Wings board, full of empty rhetoric and hyperbole, so that might not fit.
If you don't like the debate...
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by DRWCountryClub