View Single Post
04-15-2013, 05:50 PM
Join Date: Dec 2008
Originally Posted by
My ice time stats aren't obsurd. They aren't even mine, they come from the NHL's website. If your above ES ice time stats are indeed accurate (I don't have them, so I'll take your word for it) then I'll bow to your knowledge on this issue. I also have not seen Sutter's post-game quotes, so I can't comment on those either.
Essentially though, this is all a sideshow to the real issue, mainly on whether or not Bud was way down the depth chart or not. Bottom line is, heding into camp, there were two open roster spots until Ethan Moreau and Trent Hunter came into the scene, which was after Holloway left for Sweden. He'd have had a chance to beat those guys in camp for a spot. And frankly,
if Holloway couldn't compete to those two, he didn't deserve to be in the NHL and on a one-way deal anyways. King and Nolan couldn't, seeing as they didn't beat out Moreau and Hunter in camp, so if you're going to say that Holloway couldn't beat out either of them (especially Hunter since he was on a try-out until he made the team and then was signed to a contract) then really, did DL make an error on not giving him a one-way deal?
The answer is no. And, as I've said all along, neither did Bud make a mistake going to Europe. It really is possible for two people to make opposite decisions and it be the right one for each of them. I've said this all along, I don't really understand your desire to hammer away at the belief DL did some large disservice to the team but not giving in to Bud.
I don't disagree with that -- my point was that by the time contract time came around it was too late to salvage the situation. He should have given Bud a sip before or at least told him he truly loved him or something or other. Instead, Bud took a powder and with good reason from his POV. I never said DL should have given him a 1 way contract -- just that he should have anticipated the problem.
The fact that DL was taken totally by surprise tells me 1 of two things happened a) he didn't realize how quickly Bud would be an UFA b) he wasn't communicating sufficiently with him on his status in the organization.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by HookKing