View Single Post
04-24-2013, 08:26 PM
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Smashville, TN
Originally Posted by
In a top 6 role Butler might be better, but we don't want Butler in our top 6, I expect better than Butler and Spaling in the top 6.
In the bottom 6 checking line, energy role, Spaling is way better, Spaling is the better pker, I also think Spaling has a far better shot.
I don't think though it will come down to Butler battling Spaling for a spot, they're not the same type of player or even the same position.
It might come down to Buttler versus Beck though, in which that case, Beck smokes him.
I agree on Beck. Spaling is better defensively. I do understand they play different roles. Spaling was mentioned woth a list of other players. IMO Butler is better offensively. The eye test shows it and the numbers based on games played proves it.
Trotz said the players on the team are to much alike and we needed size. Who is he talking about if it is not SK, Yip, Hali, Spaling?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by PFL615