View Single Post
Old
04-25-2013, 08:19 PM
  #217
Foppa2118
Release Evertroll
 
Foppa2118's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Country: United States
Posts: 21,324
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by XX View Post
You are aware of the hype that surrounded Daigle, right? And that people said the exact same things about him, and about many of the names below. You don't have a crystal ball. History has taught us that you should know better than to say such things. MacKinnon could go on to be the next Tavares and it doesn't matter. You don't make that trade, given the risk. Let some other team take that risk and potentially reap the rewards. The Coyotes have zero business doing something so risky.
Daigle was drafted in 1993 when scouting and exposure wasn't what it is now, and is a huge rarity.

It's not really my place to argue much in terms of what you will and won't trade Yandle for. That's your opinion, and I'm not a Coyotes fan. I disagree with the risk of busting though in terms of MacKinnon, and what value that gives him in terms of trading a guy like Yandle.

If you're expecting a top five forward in the NHL like you are worried Mac won't become, for Yandle, that is gonna be a tough sell. If the low end for MacKinnon is Jordan Staal like you mentioned, that seems like it should be a good deal for Yandle. Especially since Phoenix will still have a sold D, and MacKinnon still has upside to be better than Staal.

Here's the top two forwards taken in the draft going back to 2000. The only ones that are disappointments are Upshall and Filatov, and they were the second forward taken with the 6th pick in weak drafts for forwards. Neither of which is very likely to be said about MacKinnon or this draft.

2000

Heatley (2)
Gaborik (3)

2001

Kovalchuk (1)
Spezza (2)

2002

Nash (1)
Upshall (6)

2003

E. Staal (2)
Horton (3)

2004

Ovechkin (1)
Malkin (2)

2005

Crosby (1)
Ryan (2)

2006

J. Staal (2)
Toews (3)

2007

P. Kane (1)
JVR (2)

2008

Stamkos (1)
Filatov (6)

2009

Tavares (1)
Duchene (3)

2010

Hall (1)
Seguin (2)

2011

RNH (1)
Landeskog (2)

2012

Yakupov (1)
Galchenyuk (3)

Foppa2118 is offline   Reply With Quote