Thread: Proposal: Edmonton - Nashville
View Single Post
Old
05-02-2013, 06:51 PM
  #3
MPStoEberletoHall
Registered User
 
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 2,143
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by oilersfan87 View Post
Note: If I was Mactavish and Poile said "if you change the first to 2013 we have a deal" I'd hesitate for a while but eventually accept because of how much Weber could help the oilers.

Weber


Eberle
Petry
2014 1st round pick

Why it makes sense for Nashville:
After a tough season Nashville begins a rebuild by trading their best defenseman (and one of the best defenseman in the league) for a young scorer, a young defenseman and a first round pick. Nashville obviously needs offense and Eberle, Barkov, Forsberg, and Wilson is a good young core to build around. Since Nashville is sending a defenseman to Edmonton they also add another defenseman that can step into the lineup in Petry. Also, another first round pick obviously helps a rebuilding team as well.

Why it makes sense for Edmonton:
Edmonton needs to make a big trade. Eberle is the most likely of the big 4 to be traded and the oilers need a vetran player instead of relying on only young players. With Weber in the lineup there is little doubt that the oilers would at least make the playoffs next season and for many seasons to come.
No way Nashville does this. Maybe something like:

To Nashville:
Eberle
7th overall pick in 2013(Monahan)
Petry
2014 1st round pick

They then have Barkov, Monahan, Eberle, Forsberg... I wouldnt want the Oilers to do that though. They would be pretty screwed upfront

MPStoEberletoHall is offline   Reply With Quote