Who has the best top 6 D in the league?
View Single Post
09-22-2006, 09:02 PM
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Richmond, VA
Originally Posted by
He hasn't played especially well in their preseason games, has he?
Regardless, he's had one good year in his career playing with Scott Niedermayer, I don't think you can give him all too much credit. I think he's a "wait and see" kind of situation.
Pronger and Niedermayer are obviously elite but O'Donnell is not made for the new NHL, Vishnevski was shipped out, and Beauchemin is a good defenseman who still has to prove last year wasn't a fluke.
Back to the topic at hand, if you make the assumption that every player in the league is completely healthy for 82 games, only a few teams with better 1-6 (or 7) depth come to mind: Calgary, Buffalo, and Phoenix, maybe Vancouver as well.
The same comment I always make when someone brings this up is to remember how many cups St. Louis won with Pronger and MacInnis.
The statement about Pronger and Niedermayer wasn't trying to say a Stanley Cup was guaranteed. How about Blake and Bourque, Niedermayer and Stevens, and Chelios and Lidstrom.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by tmntdonjuan