What if the Oilers traded up at the 79 Entry Draft?
View Single Post
05-10-2013, 02:05 PM
Join Date: Dec 2010
In 1988 the cinderella Devils might make the Finals. And get clobbered...
Gretzky, Kurri and Messier get small gains in scoring at their peaks. Gretzky and Kurri stay higher for longer and Messier doesn't boost his numbers very much post-1989. Gretzky probably steals his Harts. Bourque goes up and Coffey goes down.
I think the defensive improvement may help them survive in 1982 and 1986, though winning in 1982 is a stretch. 1983 may go longer, but the Isles still win.
1989 is a very strong year. In 1990 they don't acquire the pieces from the Carson trade, but with Bourque, Coffey, and Gretzky on their team they're probably better off.
The Oilers made the final four in 1991 and 1992 without most of their big names, and given Gretzky and Bourque I would favour them over Pittsburgh.
Having all those pieces assembled gives them a chance in 1993 and 1994, given the runs made by the Kings and Rangers.
They're still a good team post 1995, but Kurri and Anderson have long been in decline. 1995 in particular is a bad year for Fuhr, but they probably still have CuJo in 1996. Nevertheless, they probably don't make many deep runs after 1995. They probably make more deep playoff runs before that, and that wear and tear probably counteracts the improved performance from HHOF teammates.
It would be interesting to see what the lines from, say, the 1997 Oilers would look like with the HHOFers playing with the actual 90s faces and to see if they could compete with the Western Conference heavyweights.
For other teams, the Kings remain awful. Boston is an easier out in the playoffs every year. Lemieux and Fedorov have lower offensive peaks without Coffey. The Rangers never win a Cup. The Avs may not win in 2001, as Bourque stays in Edmonton forever. Vancouver is still awful from 1998-2000. Not all of the expansion teams may have been created, so the DPE probably doesn't happen as quickly or last as long. That may let Pittsburgh threaten the Avs 1996 Cup too.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by blogofmike